If we are going to make our home secure, then we’ve got to: 1) Know the mind of the would-be intruder. 2) Identify and understand the weak points in the modern home. 3) Find and obtain the best available products.
Using these DIY home security products, we will be able to reinforce known security deficiencies in today’s construction, and no longer be an easy target for those who would seek to do us harm.
You’re main entry point
For the would-be burglar, often the easiest point of entry is the same place for him as it is you; the door. Crime statistics show that just over 1/2 of all break-ins happen that way; nearly 3 every minute! And, it is basically preventable by using DIY home security products.
The door frame is made of soft wood so the builder can fit it easily into the wall frame of your house. And this works well for house construction. It’s just not too good for security. Remember, the dead-bolt tongue extends into that wood in order to lock your door. A solid, well-built dead-bolt is important, but one swift kick will still break that wood and the only thing secured is the bad guy’s entry. Swing bar locks (like you find in hotels), door security chain locks, and slide bolt latches leave you with the same problem.
5-point expectation grid
A number of different products attempt to secure your door. But most of them fall short of our expectations in 1 or more of 5 areas.
- Too cumbersome. You have to remember to turn it on or put it in place at all times, and keep setting it up and taking it down during the day.
- Inaccessible from outside. When employed, family members cannot enter the home with simplicity. The person on the inside must disengage the product for them.
- Unusable when away. You can’t use the product to secure your home from outside. When you leave, leave it’s useless.
- Unsightly. It’s not something that you want installed on your home because you simply don’t like the way it looks.
- Door jamb failure. It does not correct the original problem and work with your deadbolt.
The security alarm
These babies are popular and they prove the old adage in sales: “Don’t sell the steak, sell the sizzle.” You see, alarms do a great job of letting you know you’ve potentially been broken into. I say “potentially” because according to the University at Albany somewhere between 94 and 98% of the tens of millions of burglar alarms each year in the U.S. are false.
The reality is that alarms give a sense of security. But the facts are that they don’t do a whole lot in the area actual security. Yet sales continue to skyrocket. (Read about Ron Gronkowski burglary article here.)
Using our 5-point expectation grid, these systems fail #1. If they are not engaged, they don’t do the job. They effectively pass on #2-4. Yet they do nothing to actually make our door less penetrable, so they also fail us at #5.
The door bar
Unsightly as it may be, if installed correctly, it will likely secure your entrance. Imagine a 2×4 running across the interior side of your door like you might see on a barn. Of course, the one’s you’re likely to see for sale will be made of metal, but you get the picture. I’m guessing this won’t be your first choice if home décor is important to you.
This item falls short of most homeowners expectations in all 5 areas. However, if you’ve got something illegal going on inside your residence, you may be the exception. 🙂
The door security bar
This is an adjustable bar that works like the old chair-under-the-doorknob trick. This will add some resistance to pressure from outside the door for sure. I like this product, but more for the master bedroom door when the grand kids are around acting a little crazy and I’ve got a headache.
It is also sold as a dual-purpose item that can be used to secure your sliding glass door. The idea is to lay it in the runner so the movable door is blocked from opening. But for now, let’s just stick to the traditional 30” to 36” exterior door.
This product also comes up short on all 5 categories.
Other devices that do as good a job at preventing a break-in (or maybe even better), but still fail us in our 5 criteria, are The Door Club, The Door Jammer, Ongard Security Door Brace, a slide bolt latch, and other similar inventions.
The security storm door
These are somewhat popular, particularly in urban neighborhoods. They work in areas 1, 2 and 3 to be sure. Whether they are unsightly is really just a matter of opinion, some folks like them and some just don’t.
As to solving #5, door jamb failure, it obviously does not do that. However, if this product proves to be a strong enough deterrent and you have one on all your doors, then you don’t have to worry about that issue. On the other hand, if you have a deadbolt on your door, it’s just about useless.
The security exterior door
These are specially constructed doors made to stand up to extreme force. You can buy these, for a nice price, with steel reinforcement inside of a normal wooden door. With a door like this, the average criminal is not breaking the door down.
They are beautiful and work like any other door, even sometimes with special multi-tongue deadbolts, so they easily meet our first four needs. But if nothing is done to harden the door casing, #5 is still a problem.
The strike plate
The little piece of metal over your door jamb that the deadbolt feeds into is likely installed with ½-inch screws. The plate’s main purpose is to allow the door to close and lock snugly. Some have replaced those short screws with 3-inch ones that go through the door jamb and into the wall studs. And I think that is moving in the right direction. However, the force from a kick will still only end up being concentrated on a few screws and a small space.
Though reinforcing this product succeeds in numbers #2-5, it does not do so in the all-important area of #1; door jamb failure.
The door jamb enhancement
Imagine a 1 to 6 foot strike plate with 4 to 11 screws, all 3 inches long. When installed, this product is anchored thru the casing into the wall stud. These different products are varying lengths and prices. Some are mostly unseen and therefore attractive, while others not so much.
As to areas #1-3, we find door jamb enhancements to be successful. Regarding #4, it truly depends on which brand or type you purchase and the ease in which it installs. And concerning the all-important #5, the 4 footer with 8 screws will provide the greatest security against door jamb failure. We will review the different items in this grouping in the next post.
7 types of door security
After assessing the differing kinds of door security, we have concluded that enhancing the door casing most meets our expectations. With that in mind, we will tackle the various products that claim to secure exterior doors with this approach in our next article.
What did you like most? Do you think we missed a product type or maybe misrepresented one? Be sure to leave your questions, comments and concerns below. And remember, being informed and prepared means living without regret.